Very quickly, a follow up to the reactions to this.
Firstly, quite a few people seemed to find it interesting.
However, another quite a few people found it irritating. On the whole this seemed to be from people who didn’t appear on the list. For example Heather Yaxley thinks it’s all a bit crap really and agrees with David Brain that I need a wider list. Hmmm. I’ll try but I think 70-odd is ok to start with. I’ve since added some people to the list but only because…
… generally, the people who didn’t like it didn’t appear on it. Amanda Chapel was pretty unhappy with the first survey which included bloglines so I revised it, and now she’s unhappy that I haven’t updated it for just over a week. However, I notice that Strumpette has crept quite significantly up the Power150. Which brings me to another interesting point: given that SpudGun also got his stats off the ground, I wonder how much this chart stirred things up and helped everyone’s blog stats…?
So, what is to be done? I suppose I could just remove my list and not irritate people. But what’s the point? If people genuinely think their PR blogs are worthy then isn’t it enough to contribute to the debate? And surely isn’t one of the key learnings here the difficulty of quantifying even blog popularity, let alone influence?
Alternative approaches could be:
- Increase the reading list – so that I’m more comprehensive – although you can never include everyone and this would just take even longer to compile
- Change the metrics – so I’m not directly compared to the Power150
- Change the subject matter – so I’m out of the Power150 space altogether. I’m considering doing this for copywriting instead. I have a feeling copywriters may be less inclined to throw their toys out of the cot because they’re a sanguine lot. I know: I am one.
Finally however, to get to the real question of influence. Remember my discussion with Flemming Madsen of Onalytica about popularity vs influence, and how influence tends to resonate over time while popularity is temporary? Well, check out my blog stats chart (actual figures removed so you can’t see how puny they really are):
As you can see, after a large spike we’re now almost back to normal. So, I clearly lack influence anyway. So why all the fuss?
We’re now back to just me and my three readers. Nice.
BlinkList | Blogmarks | Digg | Del.icio.us | Ekstreme Socializer | Feedmarker | Furl | Google Bookmarks | ma.gnolia | Netvouz | New PR | RawSugar | Reddit | Scuttle | Shadows | Simpy | Spurl | Technorati | Unalog | Wink | Yahoo MyWeb2